Our Outlook for Utilities Stocks
'Til death do us part: Merger partners now tied, but power prices still deadly.
For several quarters now, utilities investors have woken to the same story. Low interest rates continue to offer an impressive tailwind for utilities that can drive earnings higher with low borrowing costs and offer investors attractive dividend yields with growth. But market-exposed power producers continue to suffer from persistently low power prices that are compressing margins for coal and nuclear operators.
For regulated utilities, the near-term outlook remains bright even as valuations stretch well beyond historical norms. A group of the 31 largest U.S.-regulated utilities returned 5% between March and June, handily beating the S&P 500's negative 3.5% return and all 11 market sectors, yet have trailed nearly all other sectors year to date. For utilities that can avoid punitive regulation, we think investors could still realize 4%-6% dividend growth to go with near-4% yields.
For power producers, fundamental changes are taking hold in power markets as coal plant shutdowns accelerate, natural gas generation skyrockets, and reserve margins face dangerous tightening during the next three to five years. We now count 35 GW of planned or executed coal plant shutdowns since late 2010, up from 30 GW last quarter and closing in on our 53 GW estimate. Gas generation in March hit its highest share of total U.S. generation in at least 40 years at 30%, while coal's share fell to its lowest level at 34%, based on the most recent government data. In May, the Texas grid operator's semiannual long-term outlook projected state reserve margins tightening below its target range as soon as next summer.
Languishing power and gas prices continue to weigh on earnings for diversified utilities and power producers. Year to date, gas prices are down 13% and power prices are down 6%. We now think earnings for most utilities with power market exposure will hit troughs in 2013-14. Coal plant operators are facing shrinking dividend coverage, liquidity concerns, and even restructuring from compressed margins and fast-approaching environmental compliance requirements.
We believe political and regulatory uncertainty are depressing power and capacity prices. Two key environmental regulations finalized in 2011 face legal challenges and political uncertainty going into the November elections. We believe power prices reflect very little of the full impact we expect from these regulations. Political intervention also appears to be depressing capacity values for emissions-controlled and clean incumbent generators. Subsidized projects in New Jersey and Maryland cut 2015-16 Mid-Atlantic capacity prices in half from our normalized estimates for certain regions, and New York is assessing subsidized generation options. Depressed power and capacity prices hurt utilities such as Exelon (EXC), GenOn Energy (GEN), and NRG Energy (NRG) the most because of their large exposure to competitive power markets.
Even if power, gas, and capacity prices stay low, we think tighter power markets and increased reliance on gas generation could lead to more volatile power prices. This should favor the largest, most diversified utilities such as Exelon, NRG Energy, and FirstEnergy (FE). These utilities moved early to pair their wholesale generation with a growing retail supply business. This pairing gives them a cost and liquidity advantage over other retailers, offering a rare competitive advantage that could lead to industry consolidation and margin expansion. Exelon in early June projected $100 million of revenue synergies from its combination with Constellation's retail business. NRG Energy is realizing similar benefits in Texas.
For all utilities, we think regulatory risk remains the key threat. The 770-basis-point spread between recently awarded allowed returns and U.S. Treasury rates is the widest in at least 20 years and 190 basis points above the 20-year average. Mean reversion would hit earnings hard. Merger approval also has been difficult, albeit successful. Regulators required rate credits, rate freezes, and/or commitments to uneconomic investments before approving Northeast Utilities' (NU) $9.5 billion acquisition of NSTAR and Exelon's $7 billion acquisition of Constellation, both of which closed this spring. These concessions will make it difficult for the companies to create value from the deals.
Similarly, Duke Energy's (DUK) $17.9 billion acquisition of Progress Energy (PGN) appears set to close by July 1, but only after the companies offered enough concessions to receive sign-off from federal regulators. Entergy's (ETR) proposed acquisition of ITC Holdings (ITC) also faces a difficult regulatory path.
Our Top Utilities Picks
On a market-capitalization-weighted basis, the average sector price/fair value ratio is 0.87, down from 0.90 last quarter. But the utility sector's 1.05 median price/fair value still highlights the sharp valuation divide we see between the relatively cheap, large diversified utilities and the relatively pricey, smaller regulated utilities.
Only two of the 33 regulated utilities we cover are trading below our fair value estimates as of mid-June. Yet paradoxically, dividend yields and growth prospects for many of those utilities still look attractive. The spread between the 4.2% utility sector average dividend yield and 10-year U.S. Treasuries at 260 basis points is the widest in at least 20 years, and most domestic utilities have no exposure to Europe's financial woes. For safety-minded, yield-seeking investors, we continue to point toward National Grid (NGG), American Electric Power (AEP), and Alliant (LNT).
Among diversified utilities and independent power producers, we still favor those with low-emissions baseload generation assets like Exelon and Ormat Technologies (ORA). As power markets tighten, we think GenOn Energy, NRG Energy, and Public Service Enterprise Group (PEG) can be winners.
|Top Utilities Sector Picks|
|Star Rating|| Fair Value |
| Economic |
| Fair Value |
|American Electric Power||$47.00||Narrow||Low||4.7%|
|Data as of 6-19-12.|
Ormat Technologies (ORA)
Ormat's baseload geothermal plants offer utilities a more appealing renewable resource than wind and solar generation, which are less reliable and often more expensive. Our bullish thesis for Ormat remains intact despite headwinds for all renewables and project delays. Ormat's relatively low-cost, clean power plants and technological edge make it the only independent power producer with a moat. We think Ormat's growth from developing existing projects could lift earnings faster than its peers with virtually no commodity exposure. We project that renewable energy demand will drive 16% annualized EBITDA growth through 2016. With an enterprise value that is 10 times our 2012 EBITDA estimate and just 7.7 times our 2014 EBITDA estimate, we think investors' negative reaction to past operational issues presents an appealing opportunity to invest in a high-quality renewable energy company.
Even though we believe Exelon's $7 billion acquisition of Constellation in March was value dilutive, the addition of Constellation's countercyclical retail business comes at just the right time. As power and gas markets have plunged, Constellation's retail business and regulated utility offer an offset to Exelon's huge generation fleet. Still, Exelon's net position remains long power, mostly in the Midwest, and it will have to overcome some $500 million of giveaways we estimate it made to gain regulatory approval. For those who concur with Exelon management that power prices will stay low for many years, the merger should easily be accretive. But if you believe Exelon can be the utility sector's big winner from environmental regulations, then Constellation will be a drag. Given our bullish outlook, we now see midcycle 2015 earnings approaching $5.80 per share, not the $6.00 we saw on a standalone basis. We still think Exelon offers a compelling value, trading at 14 times its 2014 trough earnings and 7 times our midcycle 2015 earnings.
GenOn Energy (GEN)
We think GenOn Energy provides a compelling return opportunity as a largely environmentally controlled independent power producer in constrained regions. The company is well on its way to achieving the $160 million of annual projected synergies, worth some $2 per share if they are fully realized. Synergies notwithstanding, GenOn's prospects remain closely tied to power markets in the Mid-Atlantic region. Current forward power and capacity prices are beginning to move up in response to environmental regulations announced in 2011, but significant upside remains, particularly if gas prices begin to move up on expectations for more cleaner-burning generation. GenOn's current hedges lock in what we estimate will be trough earnings in 2012. Our net asset value calculation suggests the company could be worth as much as $8 per share with synergies.
American Electric Power (AEP)
Ohio regulators introduced significant short-term uncertainty for AEP when they revoked the previously agreed-to electric security plan, or ESP, allowing AEP partial recovery for generation investments as the state transitions to full deregulation by 2015. Company management now expects less than 50% of its fleet will burn coal by 2020, compared with 64% of current generation. Despite its environmental liabilities and likely plant closures, we think AEP remains well positioned to benefit from our bullish outlook on power prices. The company's regulated utilities remain the core growth driver, with projected 9% annual earnings growth during the next five years based on its aggressive capital investment plans. Given the diversity of operations and earnings growth prospects, we believe AEP's 5% dividend yield more than compensates investors for the interim uncertainty.
National Grid (NGG)
With a 6% dividend yield and top-tier growth prospects, we think National Grid offers one of the most attractive total-return packages in the sector. This U.K.-based regulated utility should benefit substantially from a shift away from fossil fuels and toward renewables in the U.K. and the Northeast United States. Building high-return transmission grids on both sides of the Atlantic should drive strong earnings growth, while favorable regulated rate structures protect those earnings from inflation through automatic adjustments. Negotiations to determine the firm's 2013-21 U.K. rates should wrap in late 2012. Management in May raised its annualized dividend 8% for a seventh consecutive year to GBX 39 per share ($3.02 per ADR share) and has committed to a 4% increase in 2012-13. If U.K. rate negotiations remain constructive, we think management could start another similar dividend growth streak in 2013 as it pursues some GBP 40 billion of operating and capital investment through 2021.
If you'd like to track and analyze the stocks mentioned above, click here to create a watchlist. Then simply click "continue," name your watchlist, and click "done." (If this link does not work, please register with Morningstar.com--registration is free--or sign in if you're already a member, and try again.) This will allow you to save and monitor these holdings within our Portfolio Manager.
More Quarter-End Outlook Articles
Travis Miller does not own (actual or beneficial) shares in any of the securities mentioned above. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.